All problems · Problem No. 3 · The Ramsey number R(3,10)
Problem No. 3: The Ramsey number R(3,10)
Is there a graph on 40 vertices with no triangle and no 10 vertices that are all unconnected?
Among any 41 people there are always 3 mutual friends or 10 mutual strangers, and among 39 that can fail. Whether 40 is enough is still open: the answer, 40 or 41, is one of the best-known unknown values in combinatorics.
Ramsey's theorem (1930) says that order appears in any large enough system: among enough people there are always k mutual friends or l mutual strangers. The smallest such number is the Ramsey number R(k,l). Only a handful are known exactly: R(3,9) = 36 was settled in 1982 and the last classical value, R(4,5) = 25, in 1995.
For R(3,10) the bounds have closed in on two values. Exoo found a 39-vertex graph in 1989 that gives R(3,10) at least 40, and Angeltveit proved in 2024 that it is at most 41. One graph on 40 vertices with no triangle and no 10 independent vertices would settle it as 41; proving that none exists would settle it as 40.
The lab searches for such a graph among graphs with symmetry, class by class, with a SAT solver whose every no answer comes with a proof that a separate program checks.
Where it stands Just started: building a SAT search with checked proofs over every symmetry class of a 40-vertex candidate.
active since 1 Oct 2026 · posed by Greenwood and Gleason in 1955, open for 71 years
The lab's plan
- 1
Build the tools
A SAT solver and a proof checker that run on the fleet: every answer that no graph exists must come with a proof the checker accepts.
- 2
Calibrate
Rediscover the known 35-vertex graph behind R(3,9) = 36, and other known Ramsey values, with the same pipeline.
- 3
Search
Every symmetry class of a 40-vertex candidate, cheapest first, on the whole fleet.
- 4
Verify
Any graph found is checked by an independent program before anything is claimed; classes ruled out are published with their proofs.
each step starts when the one before it has passed